Abstract It has been shown that the Mere Addition Paradox occurs in a choice-functional approach with Path Independence (Stewart R.T., 2021, Path independence and a persistent paradox of population ethics, Journal of Philosophy, forthcoming). The present study is a three-part response to this finding. First, I show that Path Independence is not an essential property leading to this paradox and that logically weaker properties can get the same result. Second, I present a rationalizable choice function that does not yield the paradox. And third, I argue that menu-dependent relations are nicely examined if Path Independence is relaxed to Property $\alpha $ (or equivalently, Contraction Consistency).

Susumu Cato

Economics and Philosophy

The disciplines of economics and philosophy each possess their own special analytical methods, whose combination is powerful and fruitful. Each discipline can be enriched by the other. Economics and Philosophy aims to promote their mutual enrichment by publishing articles and book reviews in all areas linking these subjects. Topics include the methodology and epistemology of economics, the foundations of decision theory and game theory, the nature of rational choice in general, historical work on economics with a philosophical purpose, ethical issues in economics, the use of economic techniques in ethical theory, and many other subjects.

The journal "Economics and Philosophy" explores the interrelationship between the disciplines of economics and philosophy. Each discipline possesses its own unique analytical methods, and their combination can yield powerful and fruitful results. By publishing articles and book reviews that link these two fields, the journal aims to promote their mutual enrichment. Topics covered include the methodology and epistemology of economics, the foundations of decision theory and game theory, the nature of rational choice, historical studies in economics with a philosophical purpose, ethical issues in economics, the application of economic techniques in ethical theory, and many other related subjects.

《Economics and Philosophy》期刊致力于探讨经济学与哲学这两门学科之间的相互关系。经济学和哲学各自拥有独特的分析方法，而它们的结合能够产生强大而富有成效的成果。通过发表与这两个领域相关的文章和书评，期刊旨在促进它们的相互丰富。讨论的主题包括经济学的方法论和认识论、决策理论和博弈论的基础、理性选择的本质、具有哲学目的的经济学历史研究、经济学中的伦理问题、经济技术在伦理理论中的应用，以及其他许多相关主题。

Category	Quartile
哲学	2
哲学, 经济学	3
哲学, 伦理学	3

Acyclic population ethics and menu-dependent relations

ivySCI AI Smartly Parses PDF, Answers Researchers' Questions, and Helps You Understand Papers in Seconds

Journal Info